Stillwater NJ Real Estate & Homes for Sale

Discover this historic 1800s farmhouse situated on 1.20 acres in Stillwater. This charming property features a classic slate roof, a wood-burning fireplace, a 3-bay carport, and two massive barns offering endless possibilities for workshops, car enthusiasts, or extra storage! One of which has a separate furnace for heating and a separate electric meter, as this was once used for a commercial business. Inside, you'll find 4 bedrooms, 2.1 bathrooms, a bonus room/office space, a formal dining room, an open kitchen, and beautiful hardwood floors throughout. There is also the possibility of a future first-floor in-law suite, with a separate entrance, bedroom, full bathroom, wet bar, and refrigerator. Head outside to your cute lemonade porch to relax and enjoy the surrounding farmland. The property also bears peach, pear, and apple trees, as well as raspberry, quince, and strawberry bushes! The raised garden beds are also included to give you a head start on gardening! Located less than half a mile from downtown Stillwater, you'll have easy access to local amenities. Square footage taken from tax records

If you're looking for the perfect country setting, LOOK NO FURTHER! This sweet and cozy home boasts two bedrooms and one full bath with perfect rustic charm. Lots of light pours in from floor to ceiling windows as you enter into the dining room/mudroom. The wood-accented eat-in-kitchen flows into a large living room with plenty of space for gathering and gorgeous windows throughout! A quaint, peaceful setting awaits just outside your door with tons of flat, grassy area that includes an established, large garden and several outdoor workspaces (with garage doors!). THE PERFECT starter home, downsizing home or nature retreat. See for yourself!

Welcome to this unique property with lots of potential. The main house is a colonial style home which features a living room, kitchen, dining area, a family room, and full bath on the first floor. The second floor is comprised of 3 bedrooms and a full bathroom. There are two: 3 room, 1-bedroom cottages that sit on the lot as well. To help visualize this home's floor plan and to highlight its potential, photos are virtually enhanced and/or virtual furnishings may have been added to the photos found in this listing. The property is being sold 'as is' / where is. There are no seller disclosures nor representations. The buyer is responsible for the well water test. The buyer is responsible for obtaining the CCO, and smoke cert. and/or all inspections required to close.

THIS IS A ONE OF A KIND! ALMOST 30 ACRES AND A BEAUTIFUL CENTER HALL COLONIAL WITH UNBELIEVABLE VIEWS AND A WELL MAINTANED POND THAT WILL TAKE YOUR BREATH AWAY. The updated Eat-in kitchen with SS Appliances and an Island has spectacular views of the Mountains and Pond. The barn is being sold "as is". This property has endless possibilities with road frontage on Route 94 and Warner Road.

Welcome home to this bespoke Colonial set on 4+ private acres boasting 5 bedrooms, 3.5 baths, full wrap-around porch, custom pool with steel wall construction, pet safe liner and sun shelf, and exercise cottage. The gracious first floor features a designer chef's eat-in kitchen and pantry, great room with wet bar and fireplace, and an office with burn-through fireplace to oversized dining room. The open floorplan, hardwood floors throughout, and multiple French doors leading out to the wrap around porch and patios provide for sun soaked, opulent entertaining perfection. The second floor presents an additional family room, three large bedrooms, an office and a primary wing complete with two custom walk in closets, vaulted ceiling, private balcony, spa bathroom overlooking the pool and even a coffee bar. The walkout basement has a multi-generational living setup with full kitchen, bedroom, laundry, full bath and living room with separate entrance and four car tandem garage. If indoor-outdoor luxury country living with close proximity to shopping, blue ribbon schools, and NYC is your goal, make 41 Stillwater your home today!

From the minute you walk into this grand foyer you will fall in love with this stunning colonial home in Fredon Township! Completely updated first level with NEW HARDWOOD FLOORING, updated kitchen with MARBLE COUNTER TOPS and custom design touches through out! WOOD BURNING FIREPLACE, HEATED GUNITE POOL that was completely redone in 2020, new heater installed spring of 2023, pool deck recently repainted, fire pit, shed and a large FULLY FINISHED WALKOUT BASEMENT with one bedroom, full bathroom, large living room space and gym area could be a great place for guests or in-law suite are some other amazing features to this home. Property Backs to waterfall!

SPECTACULAR CENTER HALL COLONIAL WITH 10 ACRES AND A MAGNIFICANT POND AND A BARN. THE MOUNTAIN VIEWS ARE BREATHTAKING! This home offers an updated kitchen with SS Appliances and Center Island with Granite Countertops which includes the amazing mountain views and the welcoming Pond with endless possibilities. The large bright bedrooms have natural sunlight and hardwood flooring throughout. The oversized Living Room has a stone fireplace and walkout to the Deck. The Dining Room has a second fireplace which is perfect ambiance for entertaining.

This stunning colonial rests on nearly an acre with a large fenced yard. The gorgeous entry foyer and grand staircase add to the wow factor of this home. The formal dining room features hardwood flooring, bay window and a butler's pantry. Recently updated kitchen offers plenty of cabinetry, granite counter tops, stainless steel sink, gas cooktop, butcher block center island and separate eating area. Sliding doors lead to the spacious round decking over looking the yard and grounds... perfect spot to enjoy the sunset. The kitchen opens to the great room with gas fireplace and vaulted ceilings. The formal living room is currently being used as a play room. Living room offers gleaming hardwood flooring and picture windows.. The first floor primary en-suite offers a tray ceiling, plantation shutters, 2 walk in closets, full bath with stall shower and double vanity. The adjacent office features built in bookcases and desk. The powder room and laundry room complete the 1st floor. The 2nd floor offers 3 good sized bedrooms a jack and jill bathroom, an additional full bathroom and a spacious loft area. The basement is finished with a bedroom, storage room, gym and a massive rec room with a cozy gas fireplace...Ideal space for an in-law suite. French doors lead to the paver patio and yard. Recent updates include: windows (2021), kitchen (2023), fenced yard (2018), natural gas conversion (2023), hw heater (2023,) water softner (2023)

Step back to a period of a much simpler time in this period property with many original features, such as wide pine floors, fireplace with original crane, woodwork, doors and windows waiting for the history buff to bring it back to life. Explore the post and beam construction in the walk-up attic and basement with it's limestone foundation. A large "El" on the 1st floor offers many possibilities from home office or additional living space W/ a separate heating system. A large two story barn and a couple of outbuildings gives opportunity of animals, farming and gardening on the 8 + acres. Located in an area of town, once known as "Courson's Corner's and Smith's Corner, a bustling area of the mid 1700's to the mid 1800's, there are still many older homes dating to the period that current homeowners take pride in, puts this property in the perfect spot for restoration by a caring new steward. Come forth to the 2000's and you will find several upgrades in furnace, oil tank, roof and liner of the inground pool. It does need work, but well worth the time and effort for the connoisseur and historian of this period. Homeowners were well involved with the local history and the home comes with a history report of past owners dating to it's construction. This is an "estate",sold "as-is", all inspections for purchaser's knowledge only & recommended inspections are completed by experienced inspector for this type and age of property. All fireplaces,barn, outbuildings & pool also

OPPORTUNITY is knocking in Paulinskill Lake! Looking for unique? You've found it! This 6 bedroom, 4 FULL bath and 2 half bath home has TONS OF ROOM TO GROW! 2 car garage with openers. Colonial home has SEPARATE ENTRANCES and mirror image living space! First floor has 2 of everything! Welcoming foyers with coat closet. Just off the foyer separated by a decorative half wall are LIGHT FILLED living rooms. Living rooms open to dining area, both have sliders to MASSIVE END TO END deck that overlooks a FLAT, PRIVATE, backyard! Back inside breakfast bars separate dining area from functional kitchens, both with microwave, dishwasher, range, and refrigerators! Convenient powder room and laundry area are off kitchens and left side of home has side door to access side yard. Upstairs you'll find MIROR IMAGE FULL baths with tub/shower, linen closets, and 3 bedrooms on each side! Each side has PRIMARY bedroom with LARGE closet and ENSUITE bath with shower stall. All bedrooms have ceiling fans and laminate flooring. Both sides have attic storage. Left size has FULL basement with dry bar and could have MULTIPLE uses, just use your imagination! Right side has partial basement. Each side has it's own furnace. Paulinskill Lake offers not 1 BUT 2 BEACHES, MOTOR BOATS ARE ALLOWED, PLAYGROUND, TENNIS COURT, and for those who like to fish....BRING YOUR FISHING POLE! There are also community activities if you wish to participate. Come be a part of this AMAZING LAKE COMMUNITY!

If you value your privacy, escape to this secluded retreat surrounded by meadows and gardens. Sitting peacefully on over an acre of level land is this Cape Cod. There are only 2 homes on Maple Terrace, directly across from the pickle ball courts and an easy level walk to Beach 1. The property consists of a three bedroom home with a breezeway connecting the home to the 2 car garage. Above the garage is an "in-law" suite for visiting relatives. Evenings are peaceful and magical here, enjoy sunsets and star filled nights on the private pavered patio. Life the way you always dreamed of here at Paulinskill Lake.

This is your opportunity to create a home that reflects your style. The home needs tender loving care ,needs a new roof, a new driveway .. Sitting on a hill overlooking Ridge, surrounded by mature shade trees in the quiet Paulinskill Lake section of Stillwater, walking distance to the life guarded beaches and pickleball courts with motorboating and water skiing, kayaking and access to the 27 mile Paulinskill Trail. The 3 bedroom Ranch has a large master bedroom with en-suite full bath and a walk in closet. The two additional bedrooms are served by a second full bath. Large sunny Living Room opens to the Formal Dining Room, large Kitchen and a Family Room with a slider to the deck, overlooking the private backyard. You will appreciate the updates, boiler 2020 hot-water heater 2014. New Ductwork was installed in the attic for central air conditioning which was never installed. The home has convenient public water, and a fire hydrant nearby. This home is being sold "as-is", the condition of the home is reflected in the price. This home will not qualify for conventional financing, a renovation loan or cash would be advised. Located minutes from the County Seat, Hospital, shopping and restaurants

Needs TLC, true handyman special, fixer upper! Transform this three-bedroom, two-bathroom Colonial into your ideal home with a complete renovation. Situated on 1.7 acres near Fairview Lake, this property awaits your personal touch. Buyers are responsible for the well and septic systems. Sold strictly as is, the house comes with all furnishings except the dining room set. Entire purchase AS IS. Septic and Well AS IS.

NESTLED IN NATURE ON A BUCOLIC COUNTRY ROAD WITH APPROX 3.5 PRIVATE ACRES & AN IN-GROUND POOL IS THIS CUSTOM, SPACIOUS COLONIAL WITH AN IN-LAW OR MULIT-GENERATIONAL SUITE OF ROOMS ON THE GROUND LEVEL! ENTERTAINER'S DELIGHT! RESORT INSPIRED BACKYARD OASIS! FEATURES/UPDATES INCLUDE: 4 DECKS, NEW APPLIANCES (EXCEPT DRYER), NEW FRENCH DOORS, JULIET DECK OFF OF THE PRIMARY SUITE, NEWER EXPANSIVE PAVER PATIO, 2 STONE FIREPLACES, DOG RUN, MAIN FLOOR BEDROOM/OFFICE, ADDITIONAL KITCHENETTE & WET BAR ON THE GROUND LEVEL! TOP RATED SCHOOLS! MINUTES TO PARKS, SHOPPING, FARM TO TABLE STANDS, LAKES, HIKING, BIKING, FISHING & ANTIQUING! LOW TAXES! *SQUARE FOOTAGE IS APPROX PER THE TAX DATA + THE FINISHED WALK-OUT LEVEL* 3 BD SEPTIC*4/5 BEDROOMS: OFFICE/FLEX SPACE/BEDROOM*

Beautiful updated Contemporary home offers 3 large bedrooms with walk-in closets, total of 4 bath rooms, large living room with cherry wood floors. large dining room, oversize kitchen with plenty of cabinet space and stainless steel appliances. There is also a sunken living room off the kitchen area. Laundry room is on the first floor off the kitchen area as well. Primary bedroom with private bath with jacuzzi tube and separate title flooring with large title shower. There is also a walk up attic on the second floor. The lower level has private entrance in the back with plenty of parking and private 1/2 bath which all would make for the perfect home office. The over size garage with work shop. All situated on almost a acre of property with in ground pool in back yard and large patio area to relax during the seasons. Convenient location to many local shops.

Welcome to this charming 2-bedroom home that has been lovingly cared for over the years. This delightful property offers a wonderful blend of classic charm and modern convenience, including a large detached garage with 2 bays and a workshop area, making it perfect for car enthusiasts, hobbyists or anyone in need of extra storage or workspace.The kitchen is generously sized and open to the dining area, making it perfect for cooking and entertaining. The dining area features a wood-burning insert in the fireplace, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere for meals. While the living room fireplace is not currently functional, it adds a beautiful decorative touch to the space. Both bedrooms are located upstairs and feature newer carpeting providing a comfortable and inviting space. New Roth oil tank. Home being sold as is. Home does need a new septic.

Discover the charm of this expansive 4-bedroom, 2.5-bathroom residence, featuring a spacious 2-car garage. The first level welcomes you with elegant hardwood floors, complemented by a brand-new stove and water heater. The entire interior of the house has been freshly painted, adding a touch of modern allure. Step outside onto the expansive deck, accessible from the dining room, and admire the breathtaking 24x30 outbuilding. This is set against the backdrop of a sprawling 1.24-acre park-like property, creating a serene and picturesque setting.

TURN-KEY LOG CABIN FOR SALE! Welcome to your dream home! This stunningly updated 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath log cabin offers a perfect blend of contemporary style and cozy charm. Experience the spacious, sunlit interior adorned with beautiful beams and ample room for both comfort and entertaining. The exquisite kitchen features sleek stainless steel appliances, elegant granite countertops, and a breakfast bar that flows into the inviting dining area. Pamper yourself in the stylish bathrooms equipped with premium "Duravit" and "Toto" fixtures, complemented by chic "Robern" medicine cabinets with LED lighting for a touch of luxury. Step into your serene backyard retreat, complete with a new deck perfect for outdoor gatherings. A fully finished basement adds versatility to your living space, while updates like fresh flooring, modern windows, a new HVAC system, and a brand-new water heater ensure peace of mind. Additional features include a new filtration system and driveway, making this property a true standout! This captivating custom colonial/log cabin boasts a generous family room with a walk-in closet and sliders that open to the deck. The generous living area is enhanced by a stone-faced wood-burning fireplace, and the master suite includes a spacious walk-in closet along with a private bath. Don't wait schedule your viewing today!

Welcome to this rare find in Northwestern NJ: a stunning - nearly 200 acre compound with 3 separate homes sitting around a private lake offering the ultimate in country farm living. This well-maintained property has recently been completely upgraded by its current owner and is now available for purchase. The expansive estate features three separate dwellings, making it ideal for use as a retreat, rental opportunity/airbnb, or potential subdivision with 6-acre zoning. There is not a similar property with this large of a lake available this close to NYC. The property is equipped with a newly installed front gate and paved roads leading to an array of impressive amenities. These include a tennis court, horse barns, five additional outbuildings, two garages accommodating up to four vehicles, a workshop, storage sheds, and many other structures. This is a place where you can truly escape and decompress, surrounded by vast riding trails perfect for horses and ATVs. The homes provide a serene environment where you can relax to the sounds of nature. The estates key feature is its picturesque lake with docks, making it a paradise for the serious outdoor enthusiast. Enjoy fishing from your own body of water which is completely surrounded by your own property, this is not a shared lake. Conveniently located just minutes from I-80, this property combines the tranquility of rural living with easy access to modern conveniences. Only one hour from NYC and 25 minutes to the Pocono Mountains.

Privacy! Custom home on 15+ acres surrounded by natures beauty. Property includes 40x30 pole barn with electric and water, 2 stall barn with tack room, fencing and more. Long driveway leads to this beautiful oasis. Well maintained home includes sunroom lined with windows and skylights overlooking large trek deck, bright kitchen with center island and stainless steel appliances, formal dining room, family room with wood burning stove with stove with sliders to sun room, 3 car garage. Property offers limitless possibilities! 2 offices, laundry room and much more!

This expansive landscaped Colonial makes the perfect home or Mother/daughter! Upon arriving you are welcomed by the patio paved driveway which leads to an oversized garage with loft, with a double door exit in the rear. Enter this home from the patio paved walkway to the covered porch into the foyer, there is a formal Dining room and Living room, a fireplace in the Family room with sliders that access to the Gazebo on the deck. The eat-in Kitchen also has sliders that lead to the expansive deck with steps to the huge fenced in yard. The second level hosts a primary suite has an updated bathroom with skylight and a walk-in closet, 3 additional large bedrooms (one with another walk-in closet and built-in bookshelves). The den on the lower level may be perfect for a mother/daughter set up, the current storage room with the toilet and wet sink could be a full bath and there is even an area that could be finished for a second kitchen (cabinets are already in). The finished walk-out basement can be accessed from sliders leading from the driveway, a door leading to the 2+ car garage and sliders leading to the back patio under the deck, note the koi pond and fully stocked wood shed! You have to see this home to appreciate all that it has to offer, don't forget the raised bed garden and the firepit! There is extra parking at the rear of the property beyond the fence with a driveway cut into the curb for extra parking, great for an RVs, access into the back yard through a gate

Welcome to your dream equestrian estate, situated on 6 peaceful acres of stunning, extensive grounds! The home features 4-bedrooms, 2-bathrooms with custom features and overlooks two tranquil ponds. The Amish-built custom horse barn features 10 stalls, utility room, tack room, feed room, wash stall, heating & cooling. Each stall is precisely monitored with a camera as part of the main security system, which includes 17 cameras with night vision. The property also features a 3-stall pony barn with a run-in shed, a chicken coop and a 70x150 arena, perfect for year-round training! Situated in a prime location, just a few short miles from Rt 80 in beautiful Green Township. Don't miss your chance to own this custom home and "state-of-the-art" turnkey facility!

This is the Ranch you've been waiting for! Located in Bucolic Fredon Township, just minutes from Downtown Newton with restaurants, grocery stores & shoppes, schools, and big box shopping and only a short drive to commuting Routes - this house is the "whole package". On the main level, you have the eat-in kitchen, the living & dining areas, family room, the 4 season sun porch, and 2 full bathrooms - one ensuite and one shared - and all 4 generously sized bedrooms. On the lower level - you have a kitchenette with a full bathroom, the utility room with laundry, and a huge finished area - Perfect for separate living space, playroom, workout space, work from home - the possibilities are endless. With an inground pool, gorgeous patio with pergola, 2 car garage, new roof in 2021, new furnace in 2024, and 3 whole acres - this home has it all.

Discover the epitome of peace and luxury in this expansive home nestled on a dead end street within the tranquil community of Paulinskill Lake. Boasting 3 bedrooms, 2.1 bathrooms, and a wealth of recent upgrades, this residence offers a perfect blend of comfort and functionality. The master bedroom is a retreat featuring double closets & an en suite full bathroom. Each of the large upstairs bedrooms are adorned with massive walk-in closets, providing ample storage and space. Entertaining is a delight in the formal dining room that leads to a spacious back deck. Enjoy summer barbecues on the patio overlooking the backyard, which faces lush woods for added privacy. The spacious kitchen has undergone a complete transformation with FLOOR TO CEILING UPGRADES, including butcher block countertops, new cabinets, and SS appliances. There are NEW exterior enhancements like a new shed, new fence, NEW GARAGE & EXTERIOR DOORS, recently installed retaining wall, EXPANDED & sealed parking area, new front walkway, a SPACIOUS deck with new trex stairs, enclosed storage underneath, ALL NEW WINDOWS, updated exterior lighting, and tons of new landscaping. The interior has MANY new improvements as well, such as ALL NEW FLOORING, new interior doors, trim, remodeled master bath, an upgraded half utility bathroom, AND renovated laundry room boasting new appliances. Come see for yourself, you will not be disappointed!